Ticker

6/recent/ticker-posts

DID in film

 Here’s a list of films that include characters with Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID) or portray aspects of the condition. Note that the accuracy and sensitivity of these portrayals vary widely, and many have been criticized for perpetuating harmful stereotypes.

1957

see below
Three Faces of Eve (1957) view on prime video

Loosely based on a real case, this classic film explores a woman with three distinct personalities.
See: Multiple Personality Disorder Real Psychiatric Interview with Eve White Eve Black and Jane
This Oscar-winning movie is the true story of 'Eve', based on the clinical notes and book written by her psychiatrists, Cleckley & Thigpen - although her full actual story was only known 20 years later, when she revealed the full childhood and adult traumas she went through in her memoirs. Read more: https://traumadissociation.com/did-osdd/top-10-multiple-personality-did-movies.html


1962

David & Lisa 1962 streaming on Pluto TV
David and Lisa tells the story of a bright young man suffering from a mental illness which, among other symptoms, has instilled in him a fear of being touched. This lands him in a residential treatment center, where he meets Lisa, a similarly ill young woman who displays a split personality.

While the movie has been tagged Dissociative Identity Disorder by many people online, it's much broader and more interesting than focusing on one person with one specific disorder; it's a fascinating look at the inner thoughts and actions of different people, and how they connect and heal while changing those around them. Read more: https://traumadissociation.com/did-osdd/top-10-multiple-personality-did-movies.html


1976


Sybil (1976 DVD & 2007 JustWatch)

Based on the true story of Shirley Ardell Mason, this film depicts the journey of a woman with DID and her therapy sessions.  The 2007 version is highly truncated.

Of the two movies, the original (1976) and newest (2007, made 9 years after Sybil's death), this original is far superior, with a better script, better portrayal of trauma therapy, and Sally Field in the lead role as Sybil. One of the better depictions of Dissociative Identity Disorder in a movie. Read more: https://traumadissociation.com/did-osdd/top-10-multiple-personality-did-movies.html


2007

see below

1990

Voices Within stream on Moviephone
A woman who suffers from multiple personality disorder is found during therapy to have suffered child abuse in this fact-based story.
also on Kindle and Everand

The best choice of DID movie for psychology students, professionals or psychology buffs, and the only movie with a script written with very close involvement with a person with multiple personalities (DID): Truddi Chase, New York Times best-selling author of When Rabbit Howls. Read more: https://traumadissociation.com/did-osdd/top-10-multiple-personality-did-movies.html


1992


Raising Cain (1992) view on prime
A psychological thriller where DID is central to the plot but portrayed in a dramatic and exaggerated manner.

1995

Never Talk To Strangers view on prime video
Criminal psychologist falls for a charming, mysterious stranger, while at the same time unexplained, terrifying incidents begin occurring. 

1995

Separate Lives view on prime video
James Belushi is a ex cop that wants to become a therapist. Linda Hamilton is his instructor. When she starts noticing that strange things are happening to her, she asks him to follow her around and record what she does. The secret that she is hiding from herself might be enough to tear her apart, if someone doesn't help her first.


1996


Primal Fear (1996) view on prime video
A legal thriller involving a character accused of murder who may have DID.


1996


Persona (1966) view on prime video subtitled
A complex psychological drama often analyzed for themes of identity and self-fragmentation.

1996

Shattered Mind find on JustWatch
Heather Locklear stars in this psychological thriller as a woman who is racked by multiple personalities and confronts a horrifying past of dark secrets buried a long time ago. When her father dies she descends into a bizarre emotional world where she lashes out at her husband and two young daughters.


1998

David & Lisa (remake) 1998 watch on Moviephone
Lukas Haas portays David, a withdrawn but apparent near genius, who fears being touched. Brittney Murphy plays Lisa, a young woman seemingly suffering from split personalities who speaks only in rhymes and withdraws from anyone who doesn't speak to her likewise. Meeting in the psychiatric ward, the two's eyes lock and an obvious attraction is indicated. First each must learn to approach each other in their own sphere. Enter Sidney Poitier as a caring psychologist who helps David to come to terms with his emotional failure to deal with his father's death at an early age. Debi Mazar also appears as Lisa's case worker.


1999


Fight Club (1999) view on prime video
While not explicitly about DID, the main character struggles with a split between his conscious self and an alter ego.
This film isn't informative or helpful in understanding Dissociative Identity Disorder,[1] which it represents as a Split Personality, but it is captivating, and you'll want to watch it more than once. Read more: https://traumadissociation.com/did-osdd/top-10-multiple-personality-did-movies.html
One key difference between psychosis and Dissociative Identity Disorder is that with psychosis, they do not recognize the delusion to be false, whereas with DID, the person senses and experiences, but could more-so say, “I know this sounds crazy, but…” in which case they recognize something is off. review by the Bag System 


2000



see below
Me, Myself & Irene (2000)
A comedy starring Jim Carrey, this film blends the concept of split personalities with over-the-top humor, though not an accurate depiction of DID.

Inaccuracies in this film included the origins of the split identity as something of repressed feelings built throughout adult life. While those in supporting roles were encouraging and accepting of what caused it and that there were two distinct identities, the movie failed to portray where DID actually comes from, which could lead someone to think they can develop DID later in life. review by the Bag System 


2002

All Around Town  stream on JustWatch
A young woman, seemingly good but still psychologically disturbed from being kidnapped as a little girl, becomes the obvious suspect in a murder. 

2003


Identity (2003) view on prime video

A psychological thriller where the twist involves multiple personalities within one person.
The worst movie reviewed here. Usually it's not worth watching movies with the classic trope of the "person with multiple personalities is a serial killer but doesn't even know it" because you can usually guess both the plot and ending - and this film is no exception. This film is slightly different, but a disappointment all the same. Read more: https://traumadissociation.com/did-osdd/top-10-multiple-personality-did-movies.html

2004


Secret Window (2004) view on prime video
A thriller with dissociation elements and a major twist involving identity.'

2005

Hide and Seek

2007

Mr. Brooks 
"Kevin Costner may seem a strange choice to play an emotionally complex character like this, but he pulls it off quite well. Although the plot is a bit generic (a respected gentleman tries to cover up the fact that he is also a serial killer), it is handled pretty successfully, as we watch the constantly conflicted anti-hero trying to suppress the violent urges that overwhelm him from time to time, and hide them from his unsuspecting family at the same time."

2009

see below
The United States of Tara (2009–2011) (TV Series) view on Hulu

A more nuanced portrayal of DID through a comedic-drama lens, following a suburban mom with multiple alters.
The United States of Tara drags a huge pull to realizing the impact of this reality on both the person with DID, and on their loved ones. It does not bubble wrap anything, though leaves the truth raw, painful, while also bound by a familial love and attachment that cannot be broken by trial. review by the Bag System 

2010

see below

Frankie & Alice (2010) view on prime video

Halle Berry plays a woman with DID struggling to reconcile her multiple identities, including one that expresses racism, which contrasts sharply with her core identity.
From the title, you would expect that Frankie and Alice would be a movie about a couple called Frankie and Alice, or one person (Frankie), who has one alter (alter personality) called Alice. Neither is quite right: the movie is young African-American woman called Francine, or Frankie, with very posh, racist alter called Alice and a highly intelligent child-like alter called Genius. Read more: https://traumadissociation.com/did-osdd/top-10-multiple-personality-did-movies.html

This was among the first movies we watched about Dissociative Identity Disorder after our diagnosis. We were intrigued by the differences between the alters, such as maturity or intelligence levels, which weren’t necessarily hand-in-hand. While a younger headmate may have presented with a smaller age, her intelligence exceeded the grown up in the system. review by the Bag System 

2010


see below

A forensic psychiatrist discovers that all but one of her patient's multiple personalities are murder victims. She will have to find out what's happening before her time is finished.

2010

A train accident in rural Nebraska gradually unveils a mystery involving the town's bank clerk.

2010


Shutter Island (2010) view on prime
While the character does not have DID, the film delves deeply into dissociation and trauma-related disorders.

2010

Waking Madison view on JustWatch
A woman suffering from multiple personality disorder tries to piece back together her life.
One of the few fictional stories about DID that isn't a horror movie, Waking Madison is in our view the best based non-biographical movie about Dissociative Identity Disorder. Read more: https://traumadissociation.com/did-osdd/top-10-multiple-personality-did-movies.html 

 

Madison is a resident of New Orleans and has suicidal tendencies. To overcome her mental instability, she meets up with Dr. Elizabeth, who often videotapes her patient’s interviews. During her interviews, Madison reveals to Dr. Elizabeth about her alter egos while being them – Madison herself, Alexis, Grace, Margaret, and a little blonde girl. As Madison meanders through her past and realizes the horrid things she has done, she decides to lock herself inside her apartment and videotape everything that happens inside. After the 30th day, when Madison heads out to meet the doctor, she realizes that it was her who had the DID and the fact that she was presenting herself as the four other personalities. Later on, it is revealed to the audience that even Dr. Elizabeth is an alter ego of Madison. Gritty yet shocking and unpredictable towards the end, ‘Waking Madison’ is a one-time-watch. Source

While there were concepts that do not fit the stereotypically known symptoms of DID, there was respect of the journey to answers for Madison. I found the relationships with the Headmates to be plausible and to be how a DID system often works, with a persecutor, a host, a caretaker… and so on. review by the Bag System 

2013


Bates Motel view on prime video
A contemporary prequel to Psycho, giving a portrayal of how Norman Bates' psyche unravels through his teenage years, and how deeply intricate his relationship with his mother, Norma, truly is.

2013

Do No Harm view on JustWatch
Brilliant neurosurgeon Jason Cole must battle with his own alter-ego, Ian Price, in order to live a normal life in this modern take on Jekyll and Hyde.

2015


Mr. Robot (2015–2019) (TV Series) view on prime video
Features a character whose dissociation plays a significant role in the narrative.

2016

see below
Split (2016)
Though entertaining, this thriller by M. Night Shyamalan has been criticized for portraying DID in a highly sensationalized and inaccurate manner. 

In Split, a 24th personality is expected to emerge with superhuman abilities and a pull toward intense violence. A few major issues with Split included the stigma towards making those with DID feared to be psychopaths. Another was making the concept of splitting into alters to sound like a super power, or like it is next-level access to extra-human abilities. review by the Bag System 

2017

see below
What If It Works?  view on prime video
Adrian, an irrepressibly chirpy tech nerd, has OCD. Grace, a beautiful street artist, has multiple personality disorder. It's a love story that seems impossible. But what if it works?

While comedy was engrained in the genre to this story, it was addressed fairly accurately. The woman with DID experienced both amnesia barriers and co-consciousness. She had a very angry Headmate that I could relate to their behaviour, a sexual alter, a little, and more. The movie did represent the source of DID as trauma, though where it failed was that only one trauma occurred in order for her mind to fracture, rather than a series of them. review by the Bag System 
2019
The Planters 

2020

The Great Artist view on moviephone
A gifted artist finds himself in a broken balance between creating world class art and the all too silent struggle of self care as his life begins to unravel because of his Dissociative Identity Disorder.

2022

MoonKnight (on Apple tv)

The reality of sharing a body with another seemed jarring to Stephen, which was another realism that I appreciated. Mark seemed used to the scenario, and gave the impression that he was tired of this as well. The relationship between headmates evolved and changed from wishing to be rid of each other, to appreciating, or even recognizing a need for each other.  review by the Bag System 

2022



Petals of a Rose  view here
A woman with Dissociative Identity Disorder struggles to prevent her parts from getting triggered on Valentine's Day.

2024

Crowded Room tv series view on Apple tv
In Manhattan in the summer of 1979, a young man is arrested for a shocking crime, and an unlikely investigator must solve the mystery behind it before the true criminal strikes again. 
See also:
The Crowded Room, a TV miniseries set in 1979, follows an emotionally disturbed young man as he is questioned about his role in a shocking crime. Danny Sullivan (Tom Holland) is interrogated by a psychology professor (Amanda Seyfried), who gradually helps make sense of his confusing story.… Read More (453 words) Milligan's true story is told in the documentary Monsters Inside: The 24 Faces of Billy Milligan. Read more: https://traumadissociation.com/did-osdd/top-10-multiple-personality-did-movies.html
I'm binge watching this series now. It starts out really slow and almost disappointing. I also found the way they introduce characters at first to be wrong. But further in the episodes they make up for it and in particular Tom Holland's acting diversifies. Ultimately, you cry your eyes out for this really beautiful series.  Jane


The Entropy System reviews:
Me, Myself & Irene
Identity
Frankie & Alice
Split
The Entropy system reviews:
Sybil remake
Three Faces of Eve
6 Souls
What if it Works?
A forensic psychiatrist discovers that all but one of her patient's multiple personalities are murder victims. She will have to find out what's happening before her time is finished.

Post a Comment

0 Comments